Timeri N. Murari’s new
novel, The Small House,
corporeal and aggressive, exotic and fervent, is a
journey into the past as well as a confrontation with
contemporary angst and its accompanying fragility
of human relationships. It is both tragic and entertaining.
The Hindu.
The Small House takes on big questions of love,
fidelity, history and betrayal. It describes sex plainly,
almost to the point of bluntness. Most of all, it
creates a set of characters with whom the reader becomes
engaged, notwithstanding their weaknesses, and introduces
a series of events that readers will want to follow
to their conclusion. And that ultimately is the goal
of any writer, and any story. Dawn
As in all his novels,
there are layers, subtexts and a lot of historical
facts mixed with fiction. His eye never misses details.
The New Sunday Express.
To start with, the
book threatens to take you on a sexual ride, but through
Roopmati’s character, history and sentiment,
it runs a parallel course, bringing out the latent
and nostalgic historian in the work of this racy writer.
But once you start reading it you are swept along
on a tide to the last page. Sahara
Times.
Murari has an eye for
detail, for conversation and for character, and his
protagonists, including even peripheral ones like
Roopmati’s dissolute and drunk father are drawn
true-to-life India Today.
Murari
is an excellent writer and this book showcases his
skill with grace and nuanced prose. DNA
Murari writes lucidly
about contemporary angst with an easy, laconic style,
observing his cast of characters in Chennai, gently,
from a distance. Indian
Express.
Reviewed by David Maine
Novelist Timeri N.
Murari has displayed an impressive range over his
career, from historical epics like Taj to 2006’s
multiple-generation family drama Four Steps From Paradise;
he has also written stage plays and movies. His newest
novel, The Small House, turns an eye toward the personal
and interpersonal crises of married, professional-class
Indians, with plenty of sex and scandal to keep things
moving along.
On the face of it, the plot is simple enough. University
lecturer Roopmati suspects that her entrepreneur husband
Khris has taken a lover, just as Roopmati’s
best friend, independent filmmaker Tazneem, has learned
that her husband Hari has his own, male lover. But
the author goes further, teasing out various implicit
and explicit differences between the two situations.
Hari and Tazneem married for love, while Roopmati’s
was an arranged marriage pursued by the father to
save the family financially; Tazneem’s is an
interfaith marriage, while Roopmati’s is not;
Tazneem still loves Hari, while Roopmati never did.
And so on: Taz is devastated by Hari’s infidelity,
but Roopmati doesn’t care about Khris’s;
Hari’s lover is an indolent movie star, while
Khris’s lover is a cunning social climber; Roopmati
comes from a financially ruined family of down-on-their-luck
royalty, while Taz’s father oversees a successful
leather works empire. Khris has plenty of money, but
Hari is in deep financial crisis; Taz is close to
her father, Roopmati’s is dead. These various
permutations of relationship and character lend a
schematic feel to the book, as if each layer of involvement
— emotionally, financially, professionally,
religiously, parentally — requires a contrasting
pair of examples.
At times this formula threatens to become overwhelming.
What prevents that from happening are the stories-within-the-story:
Roopmati’s long-dead older brother, Taz’s
career as a movie director, their histories with the
men they married. These storylines — and others
— develop through a series of flashbacks and
vignettes, leaving the reader inrigued as to how everything
will turn out. Will Taz get funding for her movie?
Will she confront Hari’s lover? Will Roopmati
confront Khris’s? And what’s the meaning
of this urgent summons calling Roopmati back to her
ancestral palace?
Taz is devastated
by Hari’s infidelity, but Roopmati doesn’t
care about Khris’s; Hari’s lover is an
indolent movie star, while Khris’s lover is
a cunning social climber.
Murari can turn a phrase at times. The two friends are
reluctant to meet in a public place, lest they be overheard
by gossips: ‘The words they spoke in the morning
would return to them like a soiled bank note, faded
with overuse and barely recognisable, by the cocktail
hour.’ Yet moments later, characters are speaking
the most unlikely dialogues imaginable. One woman asks
another: ‘At which gift had he begun his metabolic
upheaval, a seismic sexual shift, imperceptible to my
eye?… For once I was dehydrated of words. There
was sand in the back of my throat and stones in my heart.’
Such ornateness might be acceptable — just barely
— in narration; it’s a lot to ask a reader
to believe that characters can actually sit around saying
such things to each other. At a beauty parlour, no less.
It’s an awful lot of disbelief to suspend.
Another jarring habit is the narrator’s inconsistent
point of view. Although there is no rule that says,
‘A chapter that begins from Roopmati’s
viewpoint must always stay there,’ it is something
that readers unconsciously expect. Chapters usually
do have one character that is the focus of the action;
if there is a conversation between two people, the
reader might bounce between the two viewpoints. But
in this book, point of view often jumps into another
character’s head merely for a sentence or two.
This is jarring in the extreme. The reader is left
wondering things like, ‘Why did the narrator
just tell me that the secretary’s mother is
pressuring her to get married, when we never, ever
see the secretary again?’ It is extraneous,
distracting information. Perhaps it’s meant
to convey some sort of richness — to suggest
that everyone has a story to tell. But it’s
not done consistently: there are plenty of characters
wandering by who don’t get a look in.
Despite these quirks, The Small House is an engaging
book. It takes on big questions of love, fidelity,
history and betrayal. It describes sex plainly, almost
to the point of bluntness. Most of all, it creates
a set of characters with whom the reader becomes engaged,
notwithstanding their weaknesses, and introduces a
series of events that readers will want to follow
to their conclusion. And that ultimately is the goal
of any writer, and any story. DAWN
For Love of History.
The Small House is a novel
about angst and the fragility of relationships.
Timeri N. Murari’s new novel, The
Small House, corporeal and aggressive, exotic
and fervent, is a journey into the past as well as
a confrontation with contemporary angst and its accompanying
fragility of human relationships. It is both tragic
and entertaining, giving a perspective that is sociologically
modem and historically a reassessment of the past
and the way it bears down on the sensitive who emotionally
cannot ever separate themselves from days gone by.
Indeed, as Nietzsche maintained, the idea of eternal
return is mysterious and perplexing.
It is the story of
two women, Roopmati and Tazneem; one who is obsessed
with saving her marriage, even though she suspects
that her husband Hari is a sexual deviant, and the
other, who, on discovering that her husband has a
mistress tucked away in The Small House, desperately
endeavours to replace the mistress to experience the
passion on the other side of the monotony of a conjugal
existence.
The burden of the
past has always been taken by Roopmati Malhotra as
an affirmative source of energy and refuge, a retreat
into the “womb of history, into the silence
of forgotten kings”. But one fine day, she receives
a strange message that sends her reeling into an entirely
different world of her childhood. She belongs to the
royal family of Krishnarangam which is one reason
why she is an ardent scholar of history, of ancient
wars and kingdoms. On the personal level, she is a
deeply emotional woman who fondly remembers her days
with her brother who supposedly died early on the
high seas.
Roopmati’s sensibilities remain charged, especially
in her dreams where she waits for a lover. It is then
that the elemental life she desires comes in full
force: ‘it had rained overnight, and the strong
smell of warm earth and water settling the restless
dust, replenished her confidence in life. Nowhere
else did such an intoxicating perfume exist and she
breathed it in deeply, holding it at as long as possible,
thinking of other times,
before releasing that memory”.
Different worlds
To her, the world of romance and her past come across
vividly unconfused in contrast to her present chaos
which she feels she can handle only in a state of
wakefulness. The world of dreams thus means more to
her than her present where she has accepted even the
daily separation from her husband when they retire
to separate bedrooms. She compares herself with the
birds that seem to agitate with the coming of the
day, ‘resenting the sun’s rise waking
them from secure dreams”. And when Roopmati
wakes up into a world of sleaze she confronts men
who get aroused by property and profit and women who
exude wiliness and are “serpentine in [their]
sexuality”.
Roopmati refuses to
negotiate with the present, finally seeking her husband
Khris approval in living for a few days in the small
house of his mistress before returning to him. She
reconciles with him after he opens up his heart and
for he first time reveals his passionate love for
her. It is she who has never tried to give herself
to him completely. The all-saving catharsis comes
in the end with the exorcising of her brother Tommy
from her troubled mind, who has turned a smuggler
and a sexual adventurer. The vanished brother whom
she reports to the police for his criminal occupation
is spurned by her. It is Khris who stands up now as
her defendant when Tommy is provoked by Roopmati and
reminded how he had once scarred her everlastingly
by calling her ‘pudge-wudge, all wobbly body,
bloody awkward” when she wanted to dance with
him with her clothes off when as little children.
She will not allow him to come anywhere near her royal
inheritance.
Open-ended
Roopmati retires to the small house with her dog
for a reprieve from her present existence. Her past
now has been tangibly intercepted by Khris standing
up for her. The open-endedness of the novel is a pointer
to Roopmati, alone in the small house, taking stock
other present life before she decides to come back
to her husband. With her brother expunged from her
life, she seems more relaxed at the end of the novel.
But it is difficult to deny that ones past has many
devious ways of encroaching upon the present. Memories
have a strange way of coming back to us, a sad reminder
that the lost period will never return. The
Hindu.
The beauty and the beast
PERHAPS the most disconcerting and yet the most entertaining
aspect of Timeri N Murari‘s latest novel is
that it has everything of everything pertaining to
the social circles that comprise, or aspire to compromise,
high society It is so contemporary within the nostalgic
refrain that ties the main, or really one of the two
main characters to an elusive past that you can almost
identify them with slight deviations with the charmed
inhabitants of Page3. High business battles with glamour
and aspiring ambitions, replete with the fashionably
abbreviated Khris — one can't say whether Khris
stands for Krishna or Christ - Malhotra, risen from
the soil to assiduously earned riches. He is therefore
able to buy the beautiful Roopmati by agreeing to
pay off the debts of her father, Nalangilli, the Raja
of Krisharanga in one of the most cynically drafted
dialogues ever of an aspiring groom asking a father
for his daughter’s hand. Within that short interchange
between the future father-in-law and the groom Murari
manages to pin point through devastatingly casual
dialogue, the status of the woman down the centuries
as a commodity for barter.
‘I don’t
want dowry,’ Khris had said in a kindly tone.
‘Pity I do’,
replies the king.
From there on it reads
like an auction house.
‘Let’s
talk money, numbers’ says the king. What’s
the business term, buyout, or is it a takeover?’
‘An acquisition,
sir,’ replies Khris. ‘Say five million.’
‘The king’s
answer is typical of the way contemporary issues are
brought in to intertwine with royal nostalgia.
“My dear boy
I never deal in small change. No one does these days,
especially our politicians.”
The king finally agrees
to seventeen million for his daughter’s ‘sale’.
It is a brilliant piece of continuing dialogue which
I’m not so sure is not the most subtly scathing
comment on the position of women. The beauteous Roopmati
is an intellectual historian to boot, “immersed”,
as her father says, “in history, her monographs,
thesis whatsoever. Nose glued to her computer screen
or in a book”. But that does not prevent this
barter and the self-prevailing tradition of a woman’s
humiliating status as evinced in Roopmati’s
subsequent unquestioning acquiescence.
The king traces this
tradition in his family to the Akbar era when Surekha,
the daughter of the then ruling King Krishnarangan
is sent off as a gift “to keep him moth- fled
and, of course”, he adds cynically, “increase
our stature.” When Khris asks him whether she
was wife or concubine, royal pride reverts to is habitual
nose in the air.
“A wife, of course.
She was a king’s daughter.”
Murari seems to have
taken up the challenge of his own very apparent concerns
about female sensibility. The book centres around
Roopmati, the beauteous historian and Tazneem, the
impetuous filmmaker. Roopmati seeks solace from the
past in which she identifies herself with the legendary
Roopmati, the commoner and beloved of Baz Bahadur
who prefers song and supremacy in the lone ramparts
of Mandu to the chilling and humiliating hierarchy
within the splendours of the King’s palace.
The present-day Roopmati wonders if her position is
not actually inferior to the songstress beloved of
Baz Bahadur who opts for her individual supremacy
even if it entails total seclusion. Roopmati, the
wife of Khris, the business magnate, feels a captive
till she replaces his mistress in the small house
which emerges as an abode and symbol of free choice.
There is on the other
hand, Tazneem. She is the volatile, tempestuous, exuberant,
maker of films, very much in love with her husband
Hari in a Hindu-Muslim contract with no repercussions
on family or social environs, very much in tune with
the sophistications that mark their milieu. Typically
the concerns that rise above the communal ones in
a society now riven by the other, more fundamental
drive towards ‘making it big’, Tasneem
finds that her husband has also found solace in the
‘other- ness’ of his identity. She comes
upon him one evening tripping down the stairs of their
home in female finery on his way out, replete, with
her diamonds in one ear. His boyfriend, she learns
later, is no other than a famous screen hero!
In fact, everything
in this book is on the level of glamour, riches and
high drama. Hari even goes off to Tirupati to have
his head shaved in retribution, but gets even his
darshan according to the status of his perceived riches.
In Tasneem’s case, however, it is her father
who comes to the help of his son-in-law to clear him
of his financial straits. That her love for her husband
remains despite his aberration brings them together
again, though not without her initial defiance. In
dramatic Indo-Englishisms and Anglo-Indian throwbacks,
the language in this book spreads across a multitudinous
area of personal relationships, nostalgic historical
forays as well as drawing a cynical portrait of present-day
corruption in areas typically talked about in social
circles. Inclusive in this is an underlying nostalgic
plea for the preservation of a rich cultural past
which demands a price nobody is willing to pay.
To start with, the
book threatens to take you on a sexual ride, but through
Roopmati’s character, history and sentiment,
it runs a parallel course, bringing out the latent
and nostalgic historian in the work of this racy writer.
The language and smiles at times are also redolent
of an earlier Indo-Anglian age. But once you start
reading it you are swept along on a tide to the last
page. Sahara Times.
TWIST IN THE FAIRYTALE.
A poor princess married to a handsome millionaire,
has a nice, modern fairytale ring to it: how more
power couple can you get? But Roopmati, impoverished
heiress to the lost kingdom of Krishnarangam, is not
happy. Bartered in marriage to the industrialist Khris
Malhotra, she retreats into a melancholy study of
history, walking the lonely rooms of the Malhotra’s
Madras mansion by day, and dreaming of her namesake,
the beautiful Rupmati who was kept by the emperor
Baz Bahadur, by night. When she’s not silently
signing business papers for Malhotra, who has moulded
his myriad businesses around the Mati brand (“She’s
my good luck charm,” he explains), she writes
papers on ancient Chola history, moons over her mysterious
missing brother Tommy, and hangs out occasionally
with her filmmaker-friend Tazneem.
Yet action is all set
to implode on this zombied and placidly unhappy front.
Tazneem and then Roopmati discover their husbands
are being unfaithful to them. Events unfold, Sidney
Sheldon-like, with much sex, scandal and intrigue.
Tazneem’s handsome husband Hari has a secret
life, including a liaison with a gay filmstar, and
Malhotra stashes away an ambitious mistress in chinnahwheedu
or the small house. All rather page-3 but pleasantly
so. Murari has an eye for detail, for conversation
and for character, and his protagonists, including
even peripheral ones like Roopmati’s dissolute
and drunk father are drawn true-to-life. As are some
episodes, like the cocktail party for Mr Schneider
or Hari’s trip to the temple at Tirupati.
And then there’s
history. Murari has always had a nice sense of it
(his Taj a sumptuous story of the building of the
Taj Mahal, offers a racy ringside view of the construction).
It’s this sense of history that comes out tops
again, setting up an intriguing backdrop of the story
of The Small House. Yes, indeed, this is how the hangover
of royal history may debilitate a family into death
debt and dissolution, and this how mere millions may
not buy it back. That said, Murari does try for a
happy resolution in an all-the-actors-come-together
climax at chinnawheedu. Accept your past the author-historian
says, and only then can you move on. INDIA
TODAY.
Big tales in a little house.
What is it about love that inspires such solemnity
and profound thought in the artist? The emotion has
driven stakes through the literary hearts of such
forlorn - if passionate - lovers as Jude Fawley, Goethe’s
Werther, Catherine Earnshaw and Maggie Tulliver. But
in The Small House, Murari dons the armour of the
ages to protect his characters from the incessant
blows of the emotion.
Indeed, this novel
is about love and its devious legions, but it is also
about the human ability to deflect its blows through
pragmatism and, strangely, a dollop of delusion.
The Small House focuses
in two couples. Roopmati the princess (she hails from
Indian royalty, distant, dead and financially bereft)
married to business tycoon Khris:
And Taz the film-star and her hapless husband Hari.
The two couples are drawn with strokes both brutally
honest, and delicately beautiful,
Murari is an excellent
writer and this book showcases his skill with grace
and nuanced prose. Roopmati’s serene grit is
perfectly juxtaposed with the cutthroat indifference
of her husband. While she delves into history with
the determination of a woman using the past to shield
her from the inevitable, Khris travels the world,
making money and slipping into the comfort of his
mistress, Maya.
Taz and Hari, however,
have none of the single-mindedness of the former couple.
Taz makes artistic films, her husband sleeps with
other men: both cling to the illusion of normalcy
with Spartan perseverance.
In the affluent world
of Chennai, want and social standing ensnare - in
their loving embrace - the lusts of those who look
for contentment, only to find ambivalence.
But it is when Tommy,
Roopmati’s brother, presumed dead, resurfaces
as the bane of her family’s heritage that the
penny drops: the curtains are swept open and the glare
of reality has to be faced.
Roopmati must come
to terms with a loveless marriage and a haunting infatuation.
Khris must learn that possession is not nine tenths
of human law. Taz must begin to comprehend her husband’s
bisexuality, and Hari must understand that his lot
has now been cast in grey, rather than the ease of
black and white.
The Small House is
a very good read, and it is the craftsmanship of Murari
that should garner the most praise, but it is in its
accomplishment as a work of prose that it stumbles,
ever so slightly. And it stumbles over the one character
that weaves the book’s narrative structure with
her deft fingers. In attempting to create an ethereal
being, Murari falters. He envisions Roopmati - the
goddess, the princess, the consummate woman - with
clarity but on the page her existence ceases to be
possible: she is too composed, too beautiful, too
elegant.
She inspires lust and
passions, and the reader may give it with abandon.
Yet there is a nagging doubt that Roopmati is but
a dream, one that we wish could be realised.
We could empathise
with Jude, cry with Werther and berate the frivolous
Maggie. Unfortunately, with Roopmati, we can do nothing,
but watch and hope that the peaceable life site craves
will be hers. DNA, Bombay.
Wedding Woes
Modern marriage, Oscar Wilde once acknowledged wryly,
thrives on mutual deception. The business of life
is still a complicated affair. It is these fragile
relationships, constantly threatened by our whimsical
choices, which form the basis of Timeri N. Murari’s
latest book The Small House. Murari writes lucidly
about contemporary angst with an easy, laconic style,
observing his cast of characters in Chennai, gently,
from a distance.
There is the emotionally cold historian Roopmati Malhotra,
from a renowned royal family, who escapes reality
by immersing herself in a dreamy past, in the parallel
life of her namesake in an ancient kingdom. Her husband
Khris, a shrewd, ruthless businessman, has some uncomfortable
secrets of his own. Then there are Tazneem, distraught,
because she has discovered her husband is homosexual;
and Hari, who has just entered a new, heady, homoerotic
world and is plagued with guilt about letting go of
his straight camouflage. Right between these fractured
lives are an ambitious and beautiful journalist, a
debauched, wayward brother and family retainers.
The title, The Small
House, refers to chinnawheedu, a Tamil term for the
home where men keep their mistresses. When Roopmati
discovers her husband has been cheating on her, she
emerges from her stupor, and reluctantly and cold-bloodedly,
assesses her marriage. She envies Tazneem her broken
heart, uneasily aware that she feels nothing at all,
except maybe curiosity. The cast, part of the city’s
cocktail circuit, is torn between keeping up appearances
and living life the way they really want to within
this insidious circle. Eventually, when they throw
their inhibitions aside, the consequences are damaging.
Murari’s writing
is occasionally flawed, yet sensitive. He draws comparisons
between a Chola bronze and feminine beauty with style,
and breezily refers to terrorism in the next sentence.
He addresses history with a flourish, like a sepia
snapshot, and suddenly conjures up delightful passages
on times gone by. His prose is melancholic and he’s
always sympathetic to his characters but it’s
unclear what exactly ails them besides monotony. The
trade-offs between family, friendship and betrayal
have been cursorily touched upon, but not explained
enough — like the baffling turn of events when
Roopmati leaves her mansion to experience life in
the small house, a bizarre attempt to rekindle passion
in her loveless marriage. The most interesting character,
the homosexual Hari trapped in marriage and riddled
by debt, is the quintessential story of gays in India
and is way too typical; we’ve heard it a hundred
times before. Tazneem’s complete acceptance
of her husband’s bisexuality also doesn’t
ring true. However, if you ignore these discrepancies
and the occasional sermonising tone, The Small House
is mostly a pacy read. There’s nothing pretentious
about Murari’s writing, he’s an accomplished
storyteller, and an entertaining one.
The 66-year-old, low-key,
almost reclusive author has focused on a similar theme
in a previous book, The Arrangements of Love: the
Chennai society where there are no secrets and everybody
is breathlessly waiting to be entertained by the next
scandal. Parties mean the small, insular circle of
acquaintances, where words spoken in the morning could
haunt them the same evening. The climax of The Small
House, Roopmati’s ultimate betrayal and her
coming to terms with her self-depiction, is sudden
and haphazard. But then, what is fiction without a
sensational twist? Indian
Express.
Sex, Scandal and More.
TIMERI MURARI’s The
Small House is the latest of his Chennai-based
novels. But it is not one of those niche novels which
can be read and enjoyed only by a hardcore South Indian.
It has a lot of Chennai in it, but also characters
and emotions which are universal.
A seriously poor princess
Roopmati of the once famous Krishnarangam royal family
is married to handsome businessman Khris Malhotra.
She is an accomplished historian who has a detached
non- romantic relationship with her husband. Her friend,
film-maker Tazneem, is married to Hari a businessman
on the decline. Unhappy Roopmati who has many secrets
and tragedies lurking in her past, and happy Tazneem
discovers their husbands are having affairs, Khris
with a woman and Hari with a man. They both have the
famous Chinna Wheedus (small houses) where they meet
their lovers.
Roopmati dreams of
her name sake, the beautiful Rupmati who was kept
by the emperor Baz Bahadur, every night. She has imaginary
conversations with her. The love of her life is her
brother who went missing by the sea years ago. Her
feelings toward her husband’s mistress is mere
curiosity but Tazneem wants her husband back.
In the interplay of
all these emotions, Murari covers many subjects —
the media, launching television channels, historical
monuments, heritage and a lot of sex and scandal.
This is possibly the first novel which reveals the
page three life of Chennai! As in all his novels,
there are layers, subtexts and a lot of historical
facts mixed with fiction. His eye never misses details.
The New Sunday Express.